How can I differentiate between cluster headaches and other types of primary headaches in a patient presenting with unilateral head pain?

Guideline-aligned answer with reasoning, red flags and references. Clinically reviewed by Dr Kola Tytler MBBS CertHE MBA MRCGP.

Posted: 16 August 2025Updated: 16 August 2025 Guideline-Aligned (High Confidence) Clinically Reviewed
Dr Kola Tytler MBBS CertHE MBA MRCGPClinical Lead • iatroX

To differentiate cluster headaches from other primary headaches in a patient with unilateral head pain, consider the following key features:

  • Location and laterality: Cluster headaches typically present with unilateral pain around or above the eye and along the side of the head/face, whereas tension-type headaches are usually bilateral and migraines can be unilateral or bilateral .
  • Pain quality and intensity: Cluster headache pain is severe or very severe and can be sharp, boring, burning, throbbing, or tightening. Tension-type headache pain is pressing/tightening and mild to moderate, while migraine pain is pulsating and moderate to severe .
  • Duration: Cluster headaches last 15 to 180 minutes per attack, occurring from once every other day to 8 times a day, often in bouts lasting weeks or months. Migraines last 4 to 72 hours, and tension-type headaches can last from 30 minutes to continuous .
  • Associated autonomic symptoms: Cluster headaches are accompanied by ipsilateral autonomic symptoms such as red and/or watery eye, nasal congestion or runny nose, swollen eyelid, forehead and facial sweating, constricted pupil, and/or drooping eyelid. These are not features of migraine or tension-type headache .
  • Effect on activities: Cluster headaches cause restlessness or agitation during attacks, whereas migraines cause avoidance of routine activities, and tension-type headaches do not aggravate daily activities .
  • Response to treatment and referral: A first bout of cluster headache requires specialist assessment and possibly neuroimaging. Acute treatment includes oxygen and subcutaneous or nasal triptans, unlike tension-type headache or migraine .

Using a headache diary to record frequency, duration, severity, associated symptoms, and medication use over at least 8 weeks can aid differentiation between cluster headache and other primary headaches ,.

Educational content only. Always verify information and use clinical judgement.