Wiki Journal Club vs iatroX (2025): Landmark Trials vs Clinical Guidelines
At a Glance
Who is it for?
iatroX:Clinicians treating patients.
Wiki Journal Club:Clinicians debating evidence / Journal Clubs.
Why choose iatroX?
- **Actionable**: Tells you the current standard of care.
- **Synthesized**: Combines multiple trials into one protocol.
- **UK Focused**: Stick to NICE (which interprets the trials for the UK).
Why choose Wiki Journal Club?
- **Primary Sources**: Detailed breakdown of inclusion/exclusion criteria for famous trials.
- **Critique**: Highlights the flaws and bias in studies.
- **Academic**: Essential for preparing for a Journal Club presentation.
Feature Comparison
| Capability | iatroX | Wiki Journal Club |
|---|---|---|
| Content | - | Trials (RCTs) |
| Goal | - | Critical Appraisal |
In-Depth Analysis
Overview
Wiki Journal Club answers "What did the study say?" It is crucial for understanding the evidence base behind our decisions (e.g., "Why do we use Dexamethasone in croup? Because of the Geelhoed trials").
iatroX answers "What does the guideline say?" It is crucial for executing the decision safely and legally.
Key Differences
Use Wiki Journal Club to sound smart in the mess room or pass an academic exam. Use iatroX to treat the patient in front of you safely.
Use-Cases
Managing AF
When to choose iatroX
- **Winner.** 'Start DOAC based on CHA2DS2-VASc'.
When to choose Wiki Journal Club
- Explains the 'ARISTOTLE' trial comparing Apixaban to Warfarin.
Hospital Meeting
When to choose iatroX
- N/A
When to choose Wiki Journal Club
- **Winner.** 'What was the NNT in the PLATO trial?'